A Brief Analysis of Fallbacks

In the process of using Xray, you must have heard about the [Fallback] function countless times. This article will briefly explain the logic and usage of this function.

1. Reviewing Fallbacks in the "Beginner's Guide"

If you used the Xray Configuration from the Beginner's Guide and completed the HTTP to HTTPS Redirection Optimization, then you already have a simple fallback based on the VLESS protocol:

json

{
  "inbounds": [
    {
      "port": 443,
      "protocol": "vless",
      "settings": {
        "clients": [
          // ... ...
        ],
        "decryption": "none",
        "fallbacks": [
          {
            "dest": 8080 // Default fallback to the probe-resistant proxy/service
          }
        ]
      },
      "streamSettings": {
        // ... ...
      }
    }
  ]
}

How do we explain this configuration in plain language?

Xray's [inbound port] is 443
This means Xray is responsible for listening to HTTPS traffic on port 443.
Xray's [inbound protocol] is vless
Only traffic using the vless protocol will flow into Xray for further processing.
WARNING
Note: The VLESS lightweight protocol was originally developed to introduce the fallback function to cores like xray and v2fly, while reducing redundant verification/encryption. (Of course, as of now, the trojan protocol in xray also fully supports the fallback function.)
The [fallback dest] is 8080
After Xray accepts traffic on port 443, traffic belonging to the vless protocol is processed internally by Xray and forwarded to the outbound module. Traffic that is not vless protocol is forwarded to port 8080.
WARNING
Q: Is it singular or plural?
A: Some sharp students may have noticed that in the configuration file, the keys are plural (inbounds, fallbacks), but when I explain them, I use the singular (inbound, fallback). Why?
Because the plural form in the configuration file indicates that xray supports N elements of the same level (i.e., N inbounds, M fallbacks, etc.). In the example analysis above, we are referring to just one of them, so I used the singular.
Traffic falling back to port 8080 is handled by a subsequent program
In the example from the Beginner's Guide, port 8080 is handled by Nginx, which finds and displays the Red Panda webpage based on its configuration.
Summary: The complete data route for the simplest fallback in the Beginner's Guide is as follows:

2. Re-understanding Fallbacks (WHAT, HOW `v1`)

Based on the example above, you should understand what a fallback is (What) and how it works (How). Simply put, it involves these elements:

The Time of fallback is after traffic enters the Xray Listening Port.
The Basis for fallback is traffic characteristics like Protocol Type.
The Target of fallback is a specific Port.
The traffic being fallen back is taken over by a subsequent program listening on the Fallback Port.

3. Why Use Fallbacks (WHY `v1`)

Initially, it was to defend against [Active Probing].

Active Probing: To put it simply and crudely, this refers to external parties sending specific network requests and interpreting the server's response to guess whether the server is running proxy tools like xray, v2fly, or shadowsocks. Once accurately identified, the server may be interfered with or blocked.

The reason interpretation is possible based on server responses is that a complete data request involves many steps of data exchange, and each step produces certain software signatures. In plain English:

A normal website response will definitely [HAVE] signatures of Web services/databases like Nginx, Apache, MySQL, etc.
A normal website response will definitely [NOT HAVE] signatures of proxy tools like xray, v2fly, shadowsocks, etc.

Therefore, when we provide the [Fallback] function to Xray (as in the example above, falling back to Nginx), the result when facing any probing request is:

Probing traffic cannot master your VLESS secrets/elements, so it will all fall back to Nginx.
Since probing traffic falls back into Nginx, the VPS server's response will definitely [HAVE] Nginx signatures.
Because Xray itself does not respond to probing traffic, the VPS response will definitely [NOT HAVE] Xray signatures.

Thus, the [Fallback] function solves the security risk of the server being [Actively Probed] from the logic of data interaction.

4. Re-understanding the [Perfect Form of Fallback] (WHAT, WHY, HOW `v2`)

Why do we need to understand fallbacks again? Because the above only explains the initial version of fallbacks based on "protocols" for resisting [Active Probing].

During the continuous development and iteration of the VLESS protocol and fallback function by RPRX, it was discovered that fallbacks could be much more flexible and powerful. As long as the premise of resisting [Active Probing] is met, by fully utilizing the information in the first data packet, multi-element and multi-level fallbacks (such as path, alpn, etc.) can be achieved.

Based on this development philosophy, the [Fallback] function has gradually grown into its current "Perfect Form," completing the evolution from Pure Camouflage --> WS Shunting --> Multi-protocol Multi-feature Shunting. The final version has even completely replaced the shunting functions that previously required Web servers or other tools. Moreover, since the aforementioned [Fallback/Shunting] processing is completed at the first packet judgment stage with millisecond-level speed and does not involve any data manipulation, there is almost no process loss.

Therefore, the [Complete Fallback Function] in Xray now possesses the following attributes:

Secure: Fully resists active probing attacks.
Efficient: Almost zero performance loss.
Flexible: Flexible data shunting, reuse of common ports (like 443).

Mr. Wordy

Although explaining it in multiple rounds seems tedious, only by peeling it back layer by layer can we fully demonstrate the unique power of the [Perfect Form of Fallback]!

5. Multi-layer Fallback Example and Interpretation

Now that you understand what the [Perfect Form of Fallback] is, you can get your hands dirty configuring multi-layer fallbacks.

5.1 First, I will extract the server-side configuration for port 443 as follows

json

{
  "port": 443,
  "protocol": "vless",
  "settings": {
    "clients": [
      {
        "id": "", // Fill in your UUID
        "flow": "xtls-rprx-vision",
        "level": 0,
        "email": "love@example.com"
      }
    ],
    "decryption": "none",
    "fallbacks": [
      {
        "dest": 1310, // Default fallback to Xray's Trojan protocol
        "xver": 1
      },
      {
        "path": "/websocket", // Must be changed to your custom PATH
        "dest": 1234,
        "xver": 1
      },
      {
        "path": "/vmesstcp", // Must be changed to your custom PATH
        "dest": 2345,
        "xver": 1
      },
      {
        "path": "/vmessws", // Must be changed to your custom PATH
        "dest": 3456,
        "xver": 1
      }
    ]
  },
  "streamSettings": {
    "network": "tcp",
    "security": "tls",
    "tlsSettings": {
      "alpn": ["http/1.1"],
      "certificates": [
        {
          "certificateFile": "/path/to/fullchain.crt", // Absolute path to your certificate
          "keyFile": "/path/to/private.key" // Absolute path to your private key
        }
      ]
    }
  }
}

How do we explain this configuration in plain language?

Xray's [inbound port] is 443
This means Xray is responsible for listening to HTTPS traffic on port 443 and uses the TLS certificate set under certificates for verification.
Xray's [inbound protocol] is vless
vless protocol traffic flows directly into Xray for subsequent processing.
Non-VLESS protocol traffic has 4 different fallback targets:
1. Traffic with path as /websocket falls back to port 1234 for processing.
2. Traffic with path as /vmesstcp falls back to port 2345 for processing.
3. Traffic with path as /vmessws falls back to port 3456 for processing.
4. All other traffic falls back to port 1310 for processing.
xver set to 1 means enabling the proxy protocol function to pass the real source IP backwards.
The fallback structure described above is shown in the diagram below:
The Web Page Fallback is missing!
That's right, clever students must have noticed that the nginx fallback for defending against [Active Probing] is gone!!! Why is that? Is it insecure? Don't worry, let's continue analyzing:

5.2 The configuration segments for subsequent listening processing are as follows

Traffic falling back to port 1310 is verified and processed according to the configuration below:

json

{
  "port": 1310,
  "listen": "127.0.0.1",
  "protocol": "trojan",
  "settings": {
    "clients": [
      {
        "password": "", // Fill in your password
        "level": 0,
        "email": "love@example.com"
      }
    ],
    "fallbacks": [
      {
        "dest": 80 // Or fallback to another probe-resistant proxy
      }
    ]
  },
  "streamSettings": {
    "network": "tcp",
    "security": "none",
    "tcpSettings": {
      "acceptProxyProtocol": true
    }
  }
}

Look, something magical happened. A new fallbacks section appeared here in the trojan protocol. As mentioned before, the trojan protocol in xray also has full fallback capabilities. So, at this point, the trojan protocol can perform judgment and fallback again (this is the legendary "Nested/Matryoshka" fallback):

All trojan protocol traffic flows into Xray for subsequent processing.
All non-trojan protocol traffic is forwarded to port 80. The defense against [Active Probing] is complete!

Traffic falling back to port 1234. Look closely! It is actually vless+ws:

json

{
  "port": 1234,
  "listen": "127.0.0.1",
  "protocol": "vless",
  "settings": {
    "clients": [
      {
        "id": "", // Fill in your UUID
        "level": 0,
        "email": "love@example.com"
      }
    ],
    "decryption": "none"
  },
  "streamSettings": {
    "network": "ws",
    "security": "none",
    "wsSettings": {
      "acceptProxyProtocol": true, // Reminder: Delete this line if using Nginx/Caddy to reverse proxy WS
      "path": "/websocket" // Must be changed to custom PATH, matching the shunting path
    }
  }
}

Traffic falling back to port 2345. Look closely! It is actually vmess direct connection:

json

{
  "port": 2345,
  "listen": "127.0.0.1",
  "protocol": "vmess",
  "settings": {
    "clients": [
      {
        "id": "", // Fill in your UUID
        "level": 0,
        "email": "love@example.com"
      }
    ]
  },
  "streamSettings": {
    "network": "tcp",
    "security": "none",
    "tcpSettings": {
      "acceptProxyProtocol": true,
      "header": {
        "type": "http",
        "request": {
          "path": [
            "/vmesstcp" // Must be changed to custom PATH, matching the shunting path
          ]
        }
      }
    }
  }
}

Traffic falling back to port 3456. Look closely again! It is actually vmess+ws(+cdn).

Explanation

You read that right. This is one of the combinations previously recommended by v2fly, and it fully supports CDN. It is now included in the perfect fallback package!

json

{
  "port": 3456,
  "listen": "127.0.0.1",
  "protocol": "vmess",
  "settings": {
    "clients": [
      {
        "id": "", // Fill in your UUID
        "level": 0,
        "email": "love@example.com"
      }
    ]
  },
  "streamSettings": {
    "network": "ws",
    "security": "none",
    "wsSettings": {
      "acceptProxyProtocol": true, // Reminder: Delete this line if using Nginx/Caddy to reverse proxy WS
      "path": "/vmessws" // Must be changed to custom PATH, matching the shunting path
    }
  }
}

With this, we can draw the complete fallback route for the template:

6. Conclusion

This concludes the introduction to Xray's [Fallback] function. I hope this article helps you understand the power of Xray.

7. Bonus Question

I will shamelessly leave a bonus question: Is there any room for optimization in the VLESS-TCP-XTLS-WHATEVER template detailed in this article?

Hint: HTTP automatic redirection to HTTPS.

A Brief Analysis of Fallbacks ​

1. Reviewing Fallbacks in the "Beginner's Guide" ​

2. Re-understanding Fallbacks (WHAT, HOW v1) ​

3. Why Use Fallbacks (WHY v1) ​

4. Re-understanding the [Perfect Form of Fallback] (WHAT, WHY, HOW v2) ​

5. Multi-layer Fallback Example and Interpretation ​

5.1 First, I will extract the server-side configuration for port 443 as follows ​

5.2 The configuration segments for subsequent listening processing are as follows ​

6. Conclusion ​

7. Bonus Question ​

A Brief Analysis of Fallbacks

1. Reviewing Fallbacks in the "Beginner's Guide"

2. Re-understanding Fallbacks (WHAT, HOW `v1`)

3. Why Use Fallbacks (WHY `v1`)

4. Re-understanding the [Perfect Form of Fallback] (WHAT, WHY, HOW `v2`)

5. Multi-layer Fallback Example and Interpretation

5.1 First, I will extract the server-side configuration for port 443 as follows

5.2 The configuration segments for subsequent listening processing are as follows

6. Conclusion

7. Bonus Question